Syllabus: GS2/International Relation
Context
- Recently, China hosted the first-ever trilateral meeting with Pakistan and Bangladesh in Kunming, on the sidelines of the China-South Asia Exposition. It has far-reaching implications for South Asia — particularly for India.
Kunming Trilateral (June 2025) – It was focused on enhancing cooperation in areas such as infrastructure, trade, maritime affairs, and climate change. 1. China, Pakistan and Bangladesh emphasized a shared vision for ‘peace, prosperity, and stability’ in the region. – It followed a similar trilateral involving China, Pakistan, and Afghanistan, signaling China’s intent to institutionalize regional groupings that exclude India while expanding the scope of the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC). |
Historical Foundations: Motivations Behind the Nexus
- 1962 War Legacy: The India-China War of 1962 set the foundation for the enduring China-Pakistan alliance.
- For China, Pakistan served as a strategic buffer to constrain India.
- For Pakistan, China emerged as an unflinching economic and military benefactor.
- Economic and Military Dependence: Pakistan owed over $29 billion to China (By the end of 2024)
- 80% of Pakistan’s arms imports originate from China.
- China continues to shield Pakistan at the UN, especially in matters involving terrorism.
- Bangladesh’s Emergence and Early Tensions: Bangladesh was carved out of Pakistan’s eastern wing in 1971.
- China, which had supported Pakistan during the 1971 war, recognized Bangladesh only in 1976.
Resurfacing of an Old Strategy: ‘China-Pakistan Plus One’
- Historical Roots: Pakistan considered leveraging China, East Pakistan, and Nepal to disrupt India’s access to its northeast via the Siliguri corridor, as far back as 1965.
- Current Manifestations: Terror attacks in Uri (2016), Pulwama (2019), and Pahalgam (2025) have seen decisive Indian retaliation.
- India’s diplomatic offensives — including suspension of treaties, trade halts, and targeted strikes — have exposed Pakistan’s vulnerabilities.
- Simultaneously, India’s border responses in Doklam (2017) and Galwan (2020) caught China off guard.
Implications for India
- Two-Front Strategic Pressure: With China to the north and Pakistan to the west, Bangladesh’s growing alignment with them potentially opens a third vector of strategic concern on India’s eastern flank.
- This triangulation could stretch India’s military and diplomatic bandwidth.
- Encirclement Anxiety: The nexus reinforces the perception of a Chinese-led strategy to encircle India, especially with the expansion of BRI and potential military cooperation in Bangladesh.
- Vulnerability To Siliguri Corridor:Siliguri Corridor (aka ‘Chicken’s Neck’) that connects mainland India to its northeastern states becomes even more critical.
- Any increased Chinese or Pakistani presence in Bangladesh could threaten this narrow corridor.
- Operational Challenges: The use of Chinese-made military hardware by Pakistan during recent escalations, and Bangladesh’s participation in Pakistani naval exercises (Aman-25), suggests greater interoperability among the three militaries.
Implications for the Indo-Pacific
- Maritime Realignment: The nexus could facilitate Chinese naval access to the Bay of Bengal via Bangladesh, complementing its presence in Gwadar (Pakistan) and Hambantota (Sri Lanka).
- It would enhance China’s ability to project power across the Indian Ocean.
- Undermining Regional Groupings: China’s trilateral diplomacy may undermine India-led regional initiatives like BIMSTEC and BBIN, while further sidelining SAARC, which has already been weakened by India-Pakistan tensions
- Quad and ASEAN Response: The U.S., Japan, Australia, and India (QUAD) may need to recalibrate their Indo-Pacific strategy to account for this emerging axis.
- ASEAN nations, particularly Myanmar and Sri Lanka, could be drawn into this evolving contest for influence.
- Economic Leverage: China’s deepening economic ties with both Pakistan and Bangladesh — through infrastructure, trade, and debt — could shift regional supply chains and investment flows away from India.
India’s Strategic Outreach
- Maldives has shifted closer to India economically despite its president’s earlier anti-India stance.
- Nepal’s BRI projects with China remain stalled due to funding concerns.
- Sri Lanka’s new leadership has visibly aligned with India’s redlines.
- India has not obstructed regional energy initiatives, despite souring ties with Bangladesh.
India’s Potential Approach
- Strategic and Military Posturing: Strengthen border infrastructure in the Northeast, especially around the Siliguri Corridor, to deter encirclement.
- Enhance maritime surveillance and naval presence in the Bay of Bengal to counter Chinese influence in Bangladesh.
- Modernize defense capabilities and increase joint military exercises with allies like QUAD.
- Diplomatic Engagement: Rebuild trust with Bangladesh through high-level visits, economic incentives, and people-to-people ties.
- Deepen ties with Afghanistan to limit Pakistan’s leverage and counter Chinese outreach.
- Assert redlines diplomatically, making it clear that provocations will have economic and political consequences.
- Economic Leverage: Expand regional trade and connectivity projects like the India-Bangladesh-Nepal energy corridor.
- Offer competitive alternatives to Chinese investments, especially in infrastructure and digital connectivity.
- Use economic tools (e.g., trade restrictions, port access denial) selectively to signal disapproval without alienating neighbors.
- Regional Coalition Building: Strengthen BIMSTEC and SAARC as platforms for regional cooperation excluding China.
- Promote trilateral and multilateral dialogues with like-minded countries to dilute China’s influence.
- Support democratic institutions and civil society in neighboring countries to counter authoritarian influence.
- Information and Cyber Strategy: Counter disinformation campaigns and propaganda that aim to destabilize India’s regional image.
- Invest in cybersecurity to protect critical infrastructure from potential threats linked to Chinese tech.
- Strategic Patience and Flexibility: Avoid overreaction to provocations; instead, use calibrated responses to maintain moral high ground.
- Adapt to regime changes in neighboring countries with pragmatic diplomacy rather than ideological rigidity.
Daily Mains Practice Question [Q] How does the emerging China-led trilateral nexus with Pakistan and Bangladesh redefine India’s strategic landscape in South Asia, and what measures could India adopt in response? |
Previous article
Reconsidering CPTPP, Integrating with ASEAN & EU
Next article
Transgender Rights & Transforming Society